The Band of Christians

"So, are you guys a Christian Band?" Every group of Christians who forms a rock band has to prepare for this answer. And how do you answer it? If you say "yes," then you are categorized with the likes of Amy Grant, Michael W. Smith, and Stryper. If you say "no," you feel like you have denied Christ... like Peter on the night Jesus was betrayed. The middle-of-the-road, safe for the whole family answer these days is, "No, but we're a band of Christians." So how do you come up with a better answer?

Between 1998 and 2000 I was in a band called se7en. At the start, we had to tackle this issue. Not wanting to be filtered out... we were leaning toward the "band of Christians" answer. There was a little problem. Our artistic vision... our agenda... was to glorify Christ through our art and to use the art to make relationships that would lead them to Christ. I don't know about you, but when your end goal as a band is to serve and glorify Christ and his gospel... you are a Christian Band.

Other artists have a similar conviction. Phil Keaggy once received a Dove award for "Best Gospel Album." Of that he said, "It's always made me feel odd when I'd get a Dove Award for an instrumental album that has nothing to do with gospel. When I think of gospel music, I think of spreading the Good News with words." [1]

Mute Math has had similar wranglings. Some of the Mute Math band members were in the Christian Band Earthsuit. And when Mute Math first formed, they appeared to be in the 'Christian Band' market (viz. the song 'Peculiar People' from their 'Reset' EP. Since then, they have broken ties with the Christian Band thing, saying, "For us, we just try to keep it simple. We're obviously a band, that's really all we ever wanted to be from the very beginning without catering to any particular genre or political or religious agenda. We just want to make music with no barriers." [2]

And really, that's what it boils down to: What is your agenda as a band?

Is your agenda Christ and His gospel? Or to encourage and build up believers?
......Then you are a Christian Band. Don't be ashamed of that.

Is that still your agenda... but you want to be free to write songs about anything... without barriers?
......IMHO, you're still a Christian Band.

Is your goal to bring people into the presence of God, to experience his grace in your life?
......Then you are a Worship Band.

Is your agenda to create music for the sake of the art... whether it's a Christian theme or not... whether anyone understands it or not?
......Then you a band... and not a Christian Band. Don't be ashamed of that, either.

So, when they ask you if you're a Christian Band: say "no" with confidence... if indeed you are not a Christian Band.

If they ask you if you are a Christian... the answer is still "yes." Don't say "no" to that one.

[1] - http://www.christianitytoday.com/music/interviews/2006/philkeaggy-0506.html
[2] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mute_Math

[Origionally posted on my Myspace on 2007-11-27]